| 3,250 | 24 | 8 |
| 下载次数 | 被引频次 | 阅读次数 |
算法伦理给脑机接口伦理问题提供了全新视角。算法的不透明性降低了人对算法和数据处理器的信任；算法的不确定性阻碍了信息可获得性和可理解性，也阻碍了信息隐私；算法的易误导特性带来了歧视问题。而算法作为驱动脑机接口的底层技术，因上述特性相应带来了安全、隐私、自我同一性、自治、责任和歧视等伦理问题。研究发现，技术层面的提高算法透明度或许存在问题，而启用算法审计和归还用户紧急制动权是必要的；非技术层面的提升编码通识水平、扩充脑机接口使用策略和重新解读责任概念和归责问题也是亟需的。
Abstract：Algorithmic ethics provides a new perspective on the ethics of brain-computer interface. The opacity of algorithms reduces people's trust in algorithms and data processors; the uncertainty of algorithms hinders the availability and understandability of information, as well as information privacy; the misleading nature of algorithms brings discrimination problems. Algorithms, as the underlying technology driving brain-computer interfaces, bring ethical issues such as security, privacy, self-identity, autonomy, responsibility, and discrimination due to the above-mentioned characteristics of algorithms. The study finds that there may be problems in improving the transparency of algorithms at the technical level, and it is necessary to enable algorithm auditing and return users' emergency braking rights. At the non-technical level, the improvement of coding literacy, the expansion of bCI usage strategies and the reinterpretation of responsibility concepts and attribution issues are also urgently needed.
[1] Bublitz C,Wolkenstein A,Jox R J,et al.Legal Liabilities of BCI-users:Responsibility Gaps at the Intersection of Mind and Machine?[J].International Journal of Law and Psychiatry,2019,65:1-12.
[2] Yuste R,Goering S,Bi G,et al.Four Ethical Priorities for Neurotechnologies and AI[J].Nature,2017,551(7679):162.
[3] Burwell S,Sample M,Racine E.Ethical Aspects of Brain Computer Interfaces:A Scoping Review[J].BMC Medical Ethics,2017,18(1):1-11.
[4] 荆珊.情感脑机接口技术应用的伦理挑战与应对[J].自然辩证法研究，2021,37(9):35-41.
[5] 顾心怡，陈少峰.脑机接口的伦理问题研究[J].科学技术哲学研究，2021,38(4):79-85.
[6] 张学义，潘平平，庄桂山.脑机融合技术的哲学审思[J].科学技术哲学研究，2020,37(6):76-82.
[7] Mittelstadt B D,Allo P,Taddeo M,et al.The Ethics of Algorithms:Mapping the Debate[J].Big Data & Society,2016,3(2):1-21.
[8] 汪德飞.算法伦理争论的六重维度及其走向[J].科学技术哲学研究，2021,38(4):59-65.
[9] Macnish K.Unblinking Eyes:The Ethics of Automating Surveillance[J].Ethics and Information Technology,2012,14(2):158.
[10] 何江新，张萍萍.从“算法信任”到“人机信任”路径研究[J].自然辩证法研究，2020,36(11):83-84.
[11] Kroll J A,Huey J,Barocas S,et al.Accountable Algorithms[J].University of Pennsylvania Law Review,2017,165:633-705.
[12] 张超.资讯类推荐算法的算法审计路径、伦理与可审计机制[J].中国出版，2021(7):31-35.
[13] Rainey S,Maslen H,Savulescu J.When Thinking Is Doing:Responsibility for BCI-mediated Action[J].AJOB Neuroscience,2020,11(1):46-58.
[14] Haselager P.Did I Do That?Brain-computer Interfacing and The sense of Agency[J].Minds and Machines,2013,23(3):414.
[15] Wolkenstein A,Jox R J,Friedrich O.Brain-computer Interfaces:Lessons to be Learned From the Ethics of Algorithms[J].Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics,2018,27(4):■.Forschungsprojekt EMOIO[C]// Bendel,Oliver.(eds.) Digitalisierung.Springer Vieweg,Berlin,Heidelberg,2018:146.
[17] Tamburrini G.Brain to Computer Communication:Ethical Perspectives on Interaction Models[J].Neuroethics,2009,2(3):137-149.
[18] Burrell J.How the Machine ‘thinks’:Understanding Opacity in Machine Learning Algorithms[J].Big Data & Society,2016,3(1):9.
[19] Scherer A G,Rasche A,Palazzo G,et al.Managing for Political Corporate Social Responsibility:New Challenges and Directions for PCSR 2.0[J].Journal of Management Studies,2016,53(3):273-98.
[20] Tamburrini G.Philosophical Reflections on Brain-computer Interfaces[C]// Grübler,Gerd,and Elisabeth Hildt.(eds.) Brain-Computer-Interfaces in Their Ethical,Social and Cultural Contexts.Springer,Dordrecht,2014:152.
(1)一场激烈的争论中,使用脑机接口的Bob怒火中烧,经由意图告知运动系统,一拳打在Alex的头上。拳头一经发出,Bob就声称他其实内心并不真的想打Alex。
基本信息:
DOI：10.19484/j.cnki.1000-8934.2022.07.013
中图分类号:TP181-2;B82-057
引用信息:
[1]王高峰,张志领.算法伦理视域下的脑机接口伦理问题研究[J].自然辩证法研究,2022,38(07):68-73.DOI:10.19484/j.cnki.1000-8934.2022.07.013.
基金信息:
中央高校基本科研业务费专项资金(YD2110002004)